D · Foreign jurisdictions / Analysis
Bank data hosted in Switzerland — but controlled by whom?
Infrastructure in Switzerland or the UK does not, on its own, guarantee legal independence from the United States. The real question is legal, technical and operational control of the data.
An IT solution can quite legitimately advertise hosting in Switzerland, the United Kingdom or another jurisdiction outside the United States. That location can give the impression that the data is beyond the reach of US law. But that reading is incomplete.
A deserved reputation
Switzerland has good reasons to inspire confidence. Banking secrecy is protected by criminal law under Article 47 of the Banking Act. Articles 271 and 273 of the Criminal Code punish unlawful acts on behalf of a foreign state and economic intelligence. The revised Data Protection Act came into force on 1 September 2023.
These protections apply in Switzerland, to those subject to Swiss law. They say nothing about what a foreign company must do when its own national law makes a demand of it.
Hosted in Switzerland, operated by whom?
Many SaaS solutions run on infrastructure operated by US groups, notably Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud, all of which have hosting regions in Switzerland. A Zurich vendor can thus sell a service “hosted in Switzerland” that runs entirely on a US provider's infrastructure.
The major providers say they challenge excessive requests and offer customer-managed encryption keys. Some are developing so-called “sovereign” offerings run by local entities. These belong in the assessment; whether they can actually shield data from US law remains debated.
The right question
Who has legal, technical and operational control over the data we entrust to our providers?
Answering it means looking well beyond the hosting location: the company that actually provides the service; the parent company and ownership links; the contracts and subcontracting terms; the cloud infrastructure used; administrative and technical access; encryption and key-management mechanisms; and access that foreign laws may impose.
| Control | To establish | Document to request |
|---|---|---|
| Legal | Contracting entity, parent, infrastructure operator | Group chart, subcontractor list |
| Technical | Who holds the keys, who can read the data | Description of key management |
| Operational | Who administers, from which country | Inventory of privileged access |
And for a Monaco bank?
Choosing Switzerland over the United States makes sense. Choosing a Swiss vendor that runs on a US cloud makes much less: you add distance from Monaco to exposure to US law. For compliance data, the easiest set-up to defend remains a provider operating in Monaco, on Monegasque infrastructure.
Digital sovereignty cannot be declared from a data centre's address. It is demonstrated through effective control of data, access and infrastructure.
References
Sources consulted as of the update date shown. Texts may have changed since; only the official version in force is authoritative.
- Swiss Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP), revised, SR 235.1, in force since 1 September 2023 — www.fedlex.admin.ch
- Swiss Federal Banking Act, SR 952.0, Article 47 — www.fedlex.admin.ch
- Swiss Criminal Code, SR 311.0, Articles 271 and 273 — www.fedlex.admin.ch
- FINMA Circular 2018/3 “Outsourcing” — www.finma.ch
- FDPIC, Swiss-U.S. Data Privacy Framework, recognition effective 15 September 2024 — www.edoeb.admin.ch
- 18 U.S.C. § 2713 (CLOUD Act) — www.law.cornell.edu
- Monaco Law No. 1.565 of 3 December 2024 on personal data protection — legimonaco.mc