Editorial theme D / F

Foreign jurisdictions

Knowing where data is stored does not tell you which law applies to it. For that, you need to look at who runs the service, who controls it, and where it is administered from.

Thesis — The law follows the company more often than the server.

Six criteria

Physical location. The operator's nationality. The parent company. Subcontractors. Where administration takes place. And finally the synthesis: which laws may apply. Each statute has its own connecting factors; you cannot say a company is subject to it without checking them one by one. That is why we never characterise the position of a named provider.

United States

What about the Patriot Act?

It is still the most quoted text, but its current role is narrower than often claimed. Enacted on 26 October 2001, it expanded the FBI's National Security Letters (18 U.S.C. § 2709), which cover subscriber and transactional records, not content. Its Section 215, on “business records”, underpinned the bulk collection of telephone metadata until the USA FREEDOM Act of 2015 ended it; it then expired on 15 March 2020. Today the texts to analyse are the CLOUD Act, Section 702 and National Security Letters. See our analysis.

European Union

The GDPR is not Monegasque law. It can nonetheless apply to a Monaco institution through Article 3(2) when it offers services to people located in the EU — which is common, given the many clients resident in France or Italy. The two regimes may then apply side by side.

United Kingdom

A UK vendor is therefore no shelter from US law: it operates in a country that has organised, by treaty, the flow of requests with the United States.

Switzerland

These protections are real, but they apply in Switzerland and to those subject to Swiss law. They do not settle the case of a service “hosted in Switzerland” on a US provider's infrastructure. See Hosted in Switzerland — but controlled by whom?

Monaco

A provider established in Monaco, running on infrastructure located in the Principality and belonging to no foreign group, is in principle subject only to Monegasque law and the applicable agreements. In our view, that is the clearest set-up for compliance data.

Analysis in this section

D · Foreign jurisdictions2 min

Bank data hosted in Switzerland — but controlled by whom?

Infrastructure in Switzerland or the UK does not, on its own, guarantee legal independence from the United States. The real question is legal, technical and operational control of the data.